Repugnance without Mere Addition

Francis, Tomi

doi:10.1017/S0266267125100631

Back

Journal article

Repugnance without Mere Addition

BHAP-PH

Francis, Tomi ORCID Université de Fribourg

2026

Published in:

Economics and Philosophy. - Cambridge University Press (CUP). - 2026, p. 1-29

English This paper concerns the difficulty of avoiding an additive version of the Very Repugnant Conclusion. An impossibility theorem is provided which shows that we cannot avoid this version of the Repugnant Conclusion even if we deny the Mere Addition Principle and closely related principles which place limits on the badness of adding happy people, such as “Dominance Addition” and additive “Non-Sadism” conditions. I argue that the impossibility theorem shows that the additive version of the Very Repugnant Conclusion cannot reasonably be avoided by population-ethical means alone. One must instead either deny structural conditions such as acyclicity, adopt a radically unorthodox fixed-population axiology, or accept this version of the Very Repugnant Conclusion.

Faculty

Faculté des lettres et des sciences humaines

Department

Département de Philosophie

Language