1 CRF

1.0.1 Data import and formatting

M_CRF <- read.csv("M_CRF_combined.csv")
M_CRF <- standardise_levels(M_CRF)

1.1 Global model.

glmer((target offspring, competitor offspring) ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate + (1|Contest), family = binomial).

Overall, ML males displayed greater mating success, with a model-estimated probability of siring offspring of 32.5%, relative to 24.3% for MC males. However, this effect also depended on interactions with female type and male genetic background, as detailed below.

m_crf <- glmer(
  cbind(Red, U) ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate +
    (1|Contest),
  data = na.omit(M_CRF),
  family = "binomial"
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_crf),
  title = "Table S1.1: Competitive reproductive fitness"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S1.1: Competitive reproductive fitness
Term Chisq Df Pr(>Chisq)
Selection 56.448 1 < 0.001
Female 0.436 1 0.509
Background 241.299 1 < 0.001
Replicate 1.785 2 0.410
Selection:Female 3.774 1 0.052
Selection:Background 17.446 1 < 0.001
Female:Background 49.498 1 < 0.001
Selection:Replicate 1.170 2 0.557
Female:Replicate 4.302 2 0.116
Background:Replicate 0.477 2 0.788
Selection:Female:Background 0.171 1 0.679
Selection:Female:Replicate 0.020 2 0.990
Selection:Background:Replicate 3.459 2 0.177
Female:Background:Replicate 0.844 2 0.656
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 5.755 2 0.056

1.2 Contrast testing.

Multiple-testing correction. Adjusted alpha for 4 contrast tests: ~0.013.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1/4)
em <- emmeans(m_crf,
  ~ Selection | Female * Background)

contrasts <- pairs(em) %>% as.data.frame()

rep_contrasts(contrasts, alpha_adj,
  "Table S1.2: Male CRF Contrasts") %>% 
  tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S1.2: Male CRF Contrasts
contrast Female Background estimate SE df z.ratio p.value
ML - MC CG CG 0.852 0.133 Inf 6.414 < 0.001
ML - MC C CG 0.661 0.137 Inf 4.831 < 0.001
ML - MC CG C 0.370 0.114 Inf 3.254 0.001
ML - MC C C 0.059 0.139 Inf 0.422 0.673

1.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_crf, response = T)
contrasts_df <- sig_ext(contrasts)
plot_glm_means_ci(plotDat, contrasts_df, title="Competitive reproductive fitness") +
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "Proportion sired",
    colour = "Selection"
  )


1.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
sim_res <- simulateResiduals(m_crf)

plot(sim_res)

par(mfrow = c(2,2))

testDispersion(sim_res)
## 
##  DHARMa nonparametric dispersion test via sd of residuals fitted vs.
##  simulated
## 
## data:  simulationOutput
## dispersion = 0.97573, p-value = 0.72
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
testOutliers(sim_res)
## 
##  DHARMa outlier test based on exact binomial test with approximate
##  expectations
## 
## data:  sim_res
## outliers at both margin(s) = 5, observations = 666, p-value = 1
## alternative hypothesis: true probability of success is not equal to 0.007968127
## 95 percent confidence interval:
##  0.00244203 0.01743245
## sample estimates:
## frequency of outliers (expected: 0.00796812749003984 ) 
##                                            0.007507508
testUniformity(sim_res)
## 
##  Asymptotic one-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test
## 
## data:  simulationOutput$scaledResiduals
## D = 0.04634, p-value = 0.1145
## alternative hypothesis: two-sided
par(mfrow = c(1,1))

2 MC success

2.0.1 Data import and formatting

M_MC <- read.csv("M_MC_combined.csv")
M_MC <- standardise_levels(M_MC)
M_MC$Success <- as.integer(M_MC$Mated.male == "wt")

2.1 Global model.

glm(Success ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate, family = binomial).

Overall, ML males were more successful in mate-choice trials, winning 305 of 535 trials, compared with 246 of 528 trials for MC males.

m_mc <- glm(
  Success ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate,
  data = M_MC,
  family = "binomial"
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_mc),
  title = "Table S2.1: Mating success"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S2.1: Mating success
Term LR Chisq Df Pr(>Chisq)
Selection 12.114 1 0.001
Female 6.145 1 0.013
Background 1.928 1 0.165
Replicate 14.171 2 0.001
Selection:Female 0.212 1 0.645
Selection:Background 0.035 1 0.852
Female:Background 0.100 1 0.752
Selection:Replicate 0.591 2 0.744
Female:Replicate 0.005 2 0.997
Background:Replicate 1.326 2 0.515
Selection:Female:Background 0.414 1 0.520
Selection:Female:Replicate 5.153 2 0.076
Selection:Background:Replicate 2.531 2 0.282
Female:Background:Replicate 1.481 2 0.477
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 0.972 2 0.615

2.2 Contrast testing.

No post hoc contrasts were required for this analysis.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1/12)
em <- emmeans(m_mc,
  ~ Selection | Female * Background * Replicate)

contrasts <- pairs(em) %>% as.data.frame()

#rep_contrasts(contrasts, alpha_adj, "Table S2.2: Male mating success contrasts") %>% 
  #tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), #data_row.padding = px(4))

2.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_mc, response = T)
contrasts_df <- sig_ext(contrasts)
plot_glm_means_ci(plotDat, contrasts_df, title="Mating success") + 
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "Proportion of successful trials",
    colour = "Selection"
  )


2.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
sim_res <- simulateResiduals(m_mc)

plot(sim_res)

par(mfrow = c(2,2))

testDispersion(sim_res)
## 
##  DHARMa nonparametric dispersion test via sd of residuals fitted vs.
##  simulated
## 
## data:  simulationOutput
## dispersion = 1.0001, p-value = 0.992
## alternative hypothesis: two.sided
testOutliers(sim_res)
## 
##  DHARMa outlier test based on exact binomial test with approximate
##  expectations
## 
## data:  sim_res
## outliers at both margin(s) = 14, observations = 1108, p-value = 0.08833
## alternative hypothesis: true probability of success is not equal to 0.007968127
## 95 percent confidence interval:
##  0.006924627 0.021109226
## sample estimates:
## frequency of outliers (expected: 0.00796812749003984 ) 
##                                             0.01263538
testUniformity(sim_res)
## 
##  Asymptotic one-sample Kolmogorov-Smirnov test
## 
## data:  simulationOutput$scaledResiduals
## D = 0.024123, p-value = 0.5393
## alternative hypothesis: two-sided

3 MC latency

3.0.1 Data import and filtering

M_MC <- M_MC %>% filter(Mated.male == "wt",
    (Mating.end.time - Mating.start.time) > 0,
    (Mating.start.time - Obs.start.time) > 0)

3.1 Global model

lm(log(latency + 1) ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate)

Successful ML males displayed lower latency to mating than MC males, mating approximately 18% faster on average (14.1 min vs 17.2 min). This likely reflects the greater mating success observed above

m_ml <- lm(
  log((Mating.start.time - Obs.start.time) + 1) ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate,
  data = na.omit(M_MC)
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_ml),
  title = "Table S3: Mating latency"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S3: Mating latency
Term Sum Sq Df F value Pr(>F)
Selection 2.725 1 3.907 0.049
Female 0.149 1 0.214 0.644
Background 0.191 1 0.274 0.601
Replicate 2.937 2 2.106 0.123
Selection:Female 0.048 1 0.069 0.792
Selection:Background 0.136 1 0.195 0.659
Female:Background 1.447 1 2.075 0.150
Selection:Replicate 2.453 2 1.759 0.173
Female:Replicate 1.104 2 0.791 0.454
Background:Replicate 0.163 2 0.117 0.890
Selection:Female:Background 0.055 1 0.078 0.780
Selection:Female:Replicate 2.732 2 1.959 0.142
Selection:Background:Replicate 0.155 2 0.111 0.895
Female:Background:Replicate 0.876 2 0.628 0.534
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 2.028 2 1.454 0.235
Residuals 363.338 521


3.2 Contrast testing

No post hoc contrasts were required for this analysis.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1)

3.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_ml, response = F)
plot_lm_means_ci(plotDat, NULL, title="Mating latency") + 
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "log(latency+1)",
    colour = "Selection"
  )


3.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
par(mfrow = c(2,2))
plot(m_ml)

par(mfrow = c(1,1))

Residual diagnostics. Residuals deviate modestly from normality; however, the deviations are minor and the model is expected to remain robust to them.

hist(
  resid(m_ml),
  main = "Residual distribution",
  xlab = "Residuals"
)

shapiro.test(resid(m_ml))
## 
##  Shapiro-Wilk normality test
## 
## data:  resid(m_ml)
## W = 0.97227, p-value = 1.228e-08

4 MC duration

4.0.1 Data import and filtering

# already covered above

4.1 Global model

lm(Duration ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate)

MC males mated for longer durations on average, mating approximately 6% longer than ML males (20.6 min vs 19.2 min). If mating duration reflects sperm investment or transfer, this suggests that ML males are not competitive through prolonged copulation. Alternatively, shorter mating durations may reflect the evolution of reduced mate harm.

m_md <- lm(
  I(Mating.end.time - Mating.start.time) ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate,
  data = na.omit(M_MC)
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_md),
  title = "Table S4: Mating duration"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S4: Mating duration
Term Sum Sq Df F value Pr(>F)
Selection 217.422 1 6.953 0.009
Female 223.731 1 7.155 0.008
Background 243.567 1 7.789 0.005
Replicate 178.077 2 2.847 0.059
Selection:Female 0.755 1 0.024 0.877
Selection:Background 55.051 1 1.760 0.185
Female:Background 1.743 1 0.056 0.813
Selection:Replicate 79.312 2 1.268 0.282
Female:Replicate 20.808 2 0.333 0.717
Background:Replicate 38.351 2 0.613 0.542
Selection:Female:Background 46.347 1 1.482 0.224
Selection:Female:Replicate 2.794 2 0.045 0.956
Selection:Background:Replicate 7.923 2 0.127 0.881
Female:Background:Replicate 34.590 2 0.553 0.576
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 84.408 2 1.350 0.260
Residuals 16,291.969 521


4.2 Contrast testing

No post hoc contrasts were required for this analysis.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1/4)
em <- emmeans(m_md,
  ~ Selection | Female * Background)

contrasts <- pairs(em) %>% as.data.frame()

4.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_md, response = F)
contrasts_df <- sig_ext(contrasts)
plot_lm_means_ci(plotDat, NULL, title="Mating duration") + 
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "Mating Duration (mins)",
    colour = "Selection"
  )


4.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
par(mfrow = c(2,2))
plot(m_md)

par(mfrow = c(1,1))

Residual diagnostics:

Residuals were broadly normally distributed, with only a small number of apparent outliers. The model is expected to be robust to these deviations.

hist(
  resid(m_md),
  main = "Residual distribution",
  xlab = "Residuals"
)

shapiro.test(resid(m_md))
## 
##  Shapiro-Wilk normality test
## 
## data:  resid(m_md)
## W = 0.87925, p-value < 2.2e-16

5 MC fecundity induction

5.0.1 Data import and formatting

M_MC <- M_MC %>% mutate(fec = Offspring_f + Offspring_m)

5.1 Global model

lm(fecundity ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate)

No detectable differences were observed between ML and MC males in the number of offspring sired following a successful mating.

m_fi <- lm(
  fec ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate,
  data = na.omit(M_MC)
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_fi),
  title = "Table S5: Offspring sired"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S5: Offspring sired
Term Sum Sq Df F value Pr(>F)
Selection 110.939 1 0.777 0.379
Female 107,596.815 1 753.372 < 0.001
Background 22,515.817 1 157.651 < 0.001
Replicate 1,106.049 2 3.872 0.021
Selection:Female 10.602 1 0.074 0.785
Selection:Background 262.289 1 1.836 0.176
Female:Background 3,069.929 1 21.495 < 0.001
Selection:Replicate 81.396 2 0.285 0.752
Female:Replicate 416.910 2 1.460 0.233
Background:Replicate 67.194 2 0.235 0.790
Selection:Female:Background 13.843 1 0.097 0.756
Selection:Female:Replicate 1.242 2 0.004 0.996
Selection:Background:Replicate 427.150 2 1.495 0.225
Female:Background:Replicate 62.697 2 0.219 0.803
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 443.010 2 1.551 0.213
Residuals 74,409.382 521


5.2 Contrast testing

No post hoc contrasts were required for this analysis.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1)

5.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_fi, response = F)
plot_lm_means_ci(plotDat, NULL, title="Offspring sired") + 
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "Fecundity Induced",
    colour = "Selection"
  ) + scale_y_continuous(limits = c(0, 65))


5.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
par(mfrow = c(2,2))
plot(m_fi)

par(mfrow = c(1,1))

Residuals revealed minor deviations from normality.

hist(
  resid(m_fi),
  main = "Residual distribution",
  xlab = "Residuals"
)

shapiro.test(resid(m_fi))
## 
##  Shapiro-Wilk normality test
## 
## data:  resid(m_fi)
## W = 0.9313, p-value = 4.067e-15

6 MC Brood sex ratios

6.0.1 Data import and formatting

M_MC <- M_MC %>%
  filter(Offspring_m + Offspring_f != 0)

6.1 Global model

lm(fecundity ~ Selection x Female x Background x Replicate)

No detectable differences were observed between ML and MC males in the number of offspring sired following a successful mating.

m_bs <- glm(
  cbind(Offspring_m, Offspring_f) ~
    Selection*Female*Background*Replicate,
  data = na.omit(M_MC), 
  family = "binomial"
)

rep_anova(
  car::Anova(m_bs),
  title = "Table S6: Brood sex ratio"
) %>% tab_options(table.font.size = px(13), data_row.padding = px(4))
Table S6: Brood sex ratio
Term LR Chisq Df Pr(>Chisq)
Selection 1.955 1 0.162
Female 0.084 1 0.771
Background 0.391 1 0.532
Replicate 0.339 2 0.844
Selection:Female 2.434 1 0.119
Selection:Background 0.357 1 0.550
Female:Background 0.099 1 0.752
Selection:Replicate 5.648 2 0.059
Female:Replicate 2.306 2 0.316
Background:Replicate 4.772 2 0.092
Selection:Female:Background 0.598 1 0.439
Selection:Female:Replicate 3.564 2 0.168
Selection:Background:Replicate 0.796 2 0.672
Female:Background:Replicate 0.575 2 0.750
Selection:Female:Background:Replicate 0.639 2 0.727

6.2 Contrast testing

No post hoc contrasts were required for this analysis.

alpha_adj <- 1 - (0.95)^(1)
em <- emmeans(m_bs,
  ~ Selection | Female * Background)
contrasts <- pairs(em) %>% as.data.frame()
contrasts_df <- sig_ext(contrasts)

6.3 Dataset visualisation

plotDat <- make_emm(m_bs, response = T)
plot_glm_means_ci(plotDat, contrasts_df, title="Brood sex ratio")  + 
  labs(
    x = "Genetic background",
    y = "Sex ratio (M/F)",
    colour = "Selection"
  )


6.4 Assumption checks

Show assumption checks
sim_res <- simulateResiduals(m_bs)

plot(sim_res)